Postby Fantasy Dreamer » Wed Sep 21, 2005 8:44 am
Well, the beating did go on a bit too long, maybe. But even though one lost his body and the other and arm and leg, they still never got scolded for it. Panako and Winry didn't scold them for breaking the laws of alchemy, and they did break a serious law. They should be punished.
The comment about the state alchemist. Well, yeah, she is a little oppinionated about them, isn't she? And she does sort of have a point, sort of. Most state alchemists are slaves to the state who would do just about anything, but the state alchemists we know wouldn't, I don't think. Especially Ed. So we know that that statement isn't entirely true.
I think the reason Al and Ed take Izumi's beating is because they respect her as their sensei. She kind of mothered them I guess when she started their training (kind of a tough love thing though with the whole teaching them how to fight and kicking their butts constantly). But notice when Edward stood up at the end of the beating he was ready for more. To me he kind of seemed to know he deserved what he was getting and was prepared to take it like a man.
So I guess what I'm trying to say is, when Izumi kicks their butts, they take it because they know that for some reason they deserve it. I know, at the beginning of the episode she slung 'em around a little bit, and they hadn't really done anything but tick her off, but notice she only kicked Ed to keep him from running and only threw Al to the ground once. And the only reason she tied them up on the train was, as you all saw, when they cut free they tried to escape. She knew they would and prevented it.
I wouldn't say she abuses them (she did hug them after beating them up, remember? Would someone who's just taking anger out on you do that?), too much. She acts like a mother to them though (i.e. she told Edward to eat and he said 'yes ma'am' when he said 'no thanks' to Winry.)
"Be strong, and let your heart take courage, all you who wait for the Lord!" - Psalm 31:24
"
MOES: Sig. Or sig not. There is no scroll."
My Fanfiction.net account
My DA account
My MAL
"An XD a post will keep humor at its most." - Goldenspines <3