With hybrids and EVs it's a trade off. You're paying more upfront to pay less in the long run. The Toyota Prius C starts at $19,080 and gets 53 city/46 hwy. The Volkswagen Jetta Turbo Hybrid starts at $27,260 and gets 42 city/48 hwy, but is a better outfitted car and has a more conventional engine concept.
The new Corolla starts at $16,800. According to this, depending on your driving habits, you would offset the difference between a base Corolla and a base Prius C in 3.5 years, and continue to spend less money. Depending on your finance term, you could be paying the car off right around that time. By no means am I trying to tell you to get a hybrid, just showing you where the offset is.