Warrior 4 Jesus wrote:I get a bit peeved when an english book that is set in LONDON in the 1890s is updated to nowdays and set in AMERICA of all places. American movie makers think the world revolves around America, or that it is the only place aliens would attack.
Warrior 4 Jesus wrote:I get a bit peeved when an english book that is set in LONDON in the 1890s is updated to nowdays and set in AMERICA of all places. American movie makers think the world revolves around America, or that it is the only place aliens would attack.
Lizardqueen, I haven't seen the recent movie but I know the book's invasion began in LONDON in 1890's and it makes much more sense to keep it in that era and location.
Mangafanatic wrote:I mean, yeah, the special affects were incredible, but the story itself was lacked strong flow. In essence the film could be broken down like this
15 minutes of character development.
1 hour of running from aliens
45 minutes of watching Tom and his daughter in a basement.
15 minutes of a lame and somewhat unexplained ending
That's one of Speilberg's trademarksMangafanatic wrote:15 minutes of a lame and somewhat unexplained ending
Overall, I just thought the movie was all about special effects and it lacked the elements which would connect the audience with the characters. Additionally, there were just some "Um, and why is it that. . ." kind of stuff. Such as:
[spoiler]At the beginning of the movie, everyone is getting vaporized by the aliens. Sudddenly, half way through, Mr. Spielberg must have decided that wasn't gruesome enough and he decided instead to make the alien suck blood. From then on, the aliens instead captured their prey and sucked the blood out of them. Nas.ty. So, why the crud was it that they changed suddenly?[/spoiler]
[spoiler] Okay, so the idea is that BILLIONS of years ago, before human life had even "evolved" on the planet's surface, the aliens planted these ships under our feet, ne? Well, so it turns out the aliens want our blood and that APPEARS to be the only reason that the creators of the film supply us with as a reason for this invasion of our planet. With that said, care to explain how it is that that works when there WEREN'T EVEN PEOPLE AROUND WHEN THE ALIEN PLANETED THEIR SHIPS HERE!?[/spoiler]
Ingemar wrote:The case for:
Alien technology that would make Half-Life 2's Striders weep.
The case against:
Already well covered by everyone else. I think Spielberg ran out of ideas. And I found Tim Robbins' character completely unecessary.
the_lizardqueen wrote:Random thought..
[spoiler]If the aliens had planted the tripods and such on earth a very, very long time ago, wouldn't they have brought some type of earth disease or bacteria back to their home planet?
I also had major issues with Ray's Ex, her new hubby and the grandparents being perfectly groomed in an undamaged house looking no worse for the wear. It would have been far more convincing for me if Ray had encountered them taking shelter in a tunnel, or even the ruins of their home..[/spoiler]
You're kidding right? it wasn't changed, the aliens either use huyman blood as a fuel source or drink it themselves. Not rocket science. OR it is VERY possible they'll use the blood to further study us for whatever reason. This is a race of intelligent beings God knows how many times more advanced than ours.At the beginning of the movie, everyone is getting vaporized by the aliens. Sudddenly, half way through, Mr. Spielberg must have decided that wasn't gruesome enough and he decided instead to make the alien suck blood. From then on, the aliens instead captured their prey and sucked the blood out of them. Nas.ty. So, why the crud was it that they changed suddenly?
Did you even pay attention to Morgan Freeman's narration?Okay, so the idea is that BILLIONS of years ago, before human life had even "evolved" on the planet's surface, the aliens planted these ships under our feet, ne? Well, so it turns out the aliens want our blood and that APPEARS to be the only reason that the creators of the film supply us with as a reason for this invasion of our planet. With that said, care to explain how it is that that works when there WEREN'T EVEN PEOPLE AROUND WHEN THE ALIEN PLANETED THEIR SHIPS HERE!?
Did you evenr ead the book/ the aliens die of bacterial infections. What? you thought the movie would end like ID4 where everything is completely blown up and destroyed? how could that be? pay attention and remember. These beings are THOUSANDS perhaps MILLIONS of times more advanced than ours. You really think we could nuke them and that would be that. They planted the Tripods and watched and recorded and studied EVERY aspect of human life and behavior. They knew how to combat and beat us.The fact the aliens planted the ships before humans "supposably" lived, just to wait a billion years to attack and cause havoc. Plus the fact the aliens died because of their immune systems... That was just a dumb way to end a movie. Oh, and who would have thought that Tom's son would surprising be alive to greet his father at the end?
What ARE you talking about? the first Tripod that rises is a taste of character development. Notice how quickly Ray went from a slacking, care free iresponsible dead beat. To a highly concerned and caring father who did not even think about his own safety but his primary goal was to get his kids safely to their mother. As well as the peanut butter sandwich scene, AND don't forget when the mob hijacked their car. Look how viciously Ray fought them off to protect his daughter, he went to the point of using a gun to threaten them off. THAT's real character development, just because the characters didn't sit around each other all fancied up while sipping a cup of tea saying "Oh how was your day my love?" doesn't mean there's no character development.And to top it off, there was little to no character development
Ashley wrote:Forgive me for not reading any of the prior posts (lest I spoil something for myself) but can anyone tell me how scary/suspenseful this movie is? I wanted to go see it, but...I'm really, really sensitive to that sort of thing. If you could compare it to a recent movie, that'd be very helpful. Thanks guys!
Return to General Entertainment
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 198 guests