I did not answer every comment you made, because for some my comments would have very little substance.
Kaori wrote:Just out of curiosity, what point, exactly, do you consider the story’s climax?
I don't. Unless I am creating a story that will benefit highly from having a well-defined or explosive climax, I rarely make an effort to distinguish them. However, if I were analyzing this story, I would say the dramatic climax is definitely the confrontation of Father, the action climax is Sasuke versus the Seven, and the emotional climax was probably back when Hinata thought Sasuke had died.
Kaori wrote:It seemed a bit ironic that the younger samurai who objected to his master’s treachery would then be willing to kill his master in cold blood after Sasuke had defeated him.
My concept of samurai honor (which isn't exactly the one of our history) doesn't really condemn killing in any way, provided that it is done honorably. In this specific case, killing the Samurai Kage was simply a matter of ending his life, as in their mindset when he lost his honor his life became worthless.
Kaori wrote:Of the various fight scenes in this chapter, I thought Sasuke's battle against the "seven" was the best. Its main virtue is its brevity: the very rapidity of the fight scene gives it a sense of cleanness.
That was my intention, so it is good to receive confirmation of this. The Hyuga-Ragnarok fight turned out to be difficult to visualize and a bit long, so I wanted the final battle to balance it, among other things.
Kaori wrote:It was good to see the significance of the story's title in the story itself, even though the word was only used in passing.
Yes, I decided that it was probably worthwhile to include it directly at least once, though I'm sure you and others understand how the idea includes the story as a whole.
Kaori wrote:Did "father" envision a time of rebirth following the downfall of shinobi, like the name Ragnarok seems to imply? If so, it would have been nice to hear a bit more about it, since that would make an interesting parallel.
Yes, that was part of the choice of the term. However, I didn't really develop the idea.
Kaori wrote:This line is terribly ironic, given Matthew’s past.
Generally speaking, I have found that many see nothing wrong in fighting fire with fire, even while condemning the fire itself.
Kaori wrote:The quieter scenes towards the end of the chapter served fairly well as resolution, and the end of the chapter in general seems like it will lead nicely into the epilogue.
Good. As for the epilogue, I may need to do some rewriting of it. It addresses many of the subtler issues of the story, which I have been changing as I edit, so the epilogue is in need of change. Depending on how quickly I can finish my projects this weekend, it may or may not be ready by next Tuesday.