SirThinks2Much wrote:I just realized...this story is mostly an "Arick's really really bad day" line-up. Of course better things will happen to him later on. Much later.
I will have to differ with you on that, Magekind. To begin with, I personally do not believe that physical descriptions of characters are particularly necessary. However, the description that is included in the chapter is used to great effect, like "freckly, golden-curled Pice," which in very few words establishes quite a vivid image.Magekind wrote:One thing you've got that plagues even my writings is a minor lack of description on your characters.
SirThinks2Much wrote:Finally Arick stood still, the separate threads in the warp of the crowd merely nudging their way around him, oblivious to his plight.
Kaori wrote: Since he is such a sympathetic character, I find myself hoping that the current series of unfortunate events does not continue to be completely unrelieved--although I believe you did indicate that his situation would not improve for quite some time.
To simply make an observation, as a reader I am slightly incredulous about the complete lack of sympathy on the part of every townsperson Arick encounters.
Kaori wrote:In general, one of the ways (in my opinion) that your writing could be most strengthened is by using more active verbs in some of your descriptions. You may have heard of the "show, don't tell" principle, and this is what I am referring to. It isn't that your descriptive writing is bad--I have already pointed out a few instances of phrases I found very effective--it is simply that the quality of the description is not as strong in some places as in others.
SirThinks2Much wrote:What was this…this thing that had the audacity to eat him?
SirThinks2Much wrote:Arick let out a roar, that sounded very unlike Arick, and ripped the sword from the creature’s throat.
SirThinks2Much wrote:Stupid animal, he thought, and it frightened him to think so vehemently at another living—or once-living—thing.
Kaori wrote:The concept of two opponents coming to a stalemate through equal incompetence is a good idea and fairly amusing]
I never thought of it that way.Kaori wrote:My only major criticism is that Arick’s whining and complaining in this chapter seems somewhat out of character. In general, he came across as morose, self-effacing, and more likely to accept hardship humbly instead of grumbling. His behavior in this chapter can partly be explained by his hunger, a state which does tend to put people in unfavorable moods, and the fact that no one is perfect—but even given that, it seems just a bit inconsistent.
I haven't looked back on these chapters since at least 3 months ago. So I have completely forgotten nearly everything prior to chapter 11...please bear in mind that this is only the first draft, but thank you very muc for pointing that out. (so the all-knowing UC-sama does NOT see everything...hmm)Kaori wrote:In contrast, I thought that Arick’s newfound assertive streak to be an interesting and fairly plausible development. This might be because you placed an emphasis on the fact that this is new and unusual behavior for Arick...
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 37 guests