I'm in the same boat as Closet Otaku. I tried Hyouka because of its great praise here, and found I just couldn't get into it.
Again my vote rests with Wolf Children.
Nooooo, just when he stopped spamming his tumblr with Oreki gifs too! ;.;GeneD wrote:I've been trawling blkmage's tumblr for a good Hyouka vote reason and I had to go three whole pages in to find anything Hyouka related. And you call yourself a fan... Anyway, my vote is for Hyouka because this thread made me want to go watch it again.
goldenspines wrote:Nooooo, just when he stopped spamming his tumblr with Oreki gifs too! ;.;GeneD wrote:I've been trawling blkmage's tumblr for a good Hyouka vote reason and I had to go three whole pages in to find anything Hyouka related. And you call yourself a fan... Anyway, my vote is for Hyouka because this thread made me want to go watch it again.
ClosetOtaku wrote:If there had been some sort of global, hidden, nascent mystery -- the Walls of Haibane Renmei, the recovery of the mother in Fullmetal Alchemist, the dual worlds of RahXephon -- I might be intrigued. Instead, I feel like I'm being treated to a slightly more slice-of-life version of "Case Closed", and I'm welcome to leave any time I like.
GeneD wrote:I'm interested in what kind of overarching mystery you'd want to see.ClosetOtaku wrote:If there had been some sort of global, hidden, nascent mystery -- the Walls of Haibane Renmei, the recovery of the mother in Fullmetal Alchemist, the dual worlds of RahXephon -- I might be intrigued. Instead, I feel like I'm being treated to a slightly more slice-of-life version of "Case Closed", and I'm welcome to leave any time I like.
Return to Anime and Anime Reviews
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 236 guests