“Dune Messiah” by Frank Herbert
The original book, “Dune”, ranks easily among the best science fiction of all time. The sequel does not. I pity the author who gets his work perfect the first time, as he must always live in his own shadow. Such is the case here.
I appreciate Herbert’s attempt, I truly do. He takes a completely different approach, choosing to focus in on two or three characters and describe the thought process that flows through each, their struggle with being able to see the future, and the way that ultimate power twists their relationships with others. It is a hearty attempt, but it is also confusing.
The dialog is not cogent like in “Dune”. It feels stilted and odd, even taking into account the fact that most people involved can see the future. This talk even manages to feel idle and petty, because by focusing on the character’s internal battles almost nothing is accomplished in the “outside world”. In “Dune”, empires were shattered and the galaxy was remade. In “Dune Messiah” nothing of that scale occurs. I know Herbert wants to focus on relationship building, but it is hard not to hold it against him.
Further, the characterizations get…. weird. An awkward romance develops, people say strange things, and people do strange things. Paul was never a normal character, but in this case he is even more detached from reality than in “Dune”. Since we are now treated to his very thoughts, he comes across less as a noble seer trying to rid the galaxy of as much suffering as possible and more a lunatic. Understandable, but not entirely pleasant.
“Dune Messiah” would be the perfect companion book to “Dune” (a sort of statistical mechanics to “Dune” thermodynamics) if all of these weird kinks had been worked out. As it stands, however, the book only decreases my interest in the series. I do not recommend it. 6/10
Neane (post: 1531185) wrote:It is a graphic novel that offers entertainment through one of the most boring sciences ever. Math!
"There is no such thing on earth as an uninteresting subject. The only thing that can exist is an uninterested person."