Postby rocklobster » Mon Mar 07, 2011 6:05 am
Ep 6: Episode 6
“Death of Shirogane the Hero”
Summary: With the Kingdom of Altea restored, the heroes begin to distribute food to the war-torn citizens only to walk into a dangerous trap of the Witch Honerva. Using a Beastman known as Galcia, she manages to kill the Blue Lion pilot “Quiet” Shirogane! How will they battle the monster Galcia without the ability to form GoLion?
Thoughts: Shirogane! NOOOO! OK, time for a rant. Anyone who saw Voltron knows this was dramatically changed in the US version. Shirogane (or Sven as he's known in our version) doesn't die in Voltron. Instead, they hastily tell us in the next episode that he's being healed on another planet. This is something I despise about TV cartoons. Why is it ok for Disney to kill Bambi's mom, or Don Bluth to kill Littlefoot's mom, but we must shield children from the very thought of death if it's a TV cartoon? I mean, for example, look at the Teen Titans' cartoon. The main villain isn't called Deathstroke, he's called Slade because even having "death" in your name is taboo. (Oh and in the original version of the Judas Contract storyline, Terra dies. She's not turned to stone, she DIES!) To me, this is unacceptable. Why? Because death is a part of life, and I don't think children should be shielded from it. You cannot possibly go through life without having someone close to you die. And death isn't always the result of violence, so even that excuse is moot. (Now I understand shielding children from graphic violence, but that's different.)
Anyway, is it just me, or does Shirogane's death seem like a poor excuse for shock value? I mean, we're given next to no background on these characters. I'm sorry, but this isn't one of the most effective death scenes for me. Yes, it's tragic, but I've seen more effective ones, mostly because we got to know the character first. Shirogane's just "the quiet one." And besides, if you look at the ending credits, you already get a spoiler because you never see him in battle gear, you see Princess Fala instead. It ruins the surprise. In fact, he's not in the sequence anywhere!