Postby ich1990 » Sat Sep 26, 2009 4:09 pm
“Dune” by Frank Herbert
I have often heard this book mentioned in the same breath as other science-fiction and fantasy greats such as “The Foundation Trilogy” and “The Lord of the Rings”. Given such a reputation, I planned to read “Dune”... eventually. In all honesty I am not fond of desert settings or sand in particular, so I took my time getting around to reading “Dune”. Once I finally started a read of it, I finished its 530 dense pages in four days; it was engrossing.
The comparisons to “The Lord of the Rings” are well founded. Like Tolkein, Herbert does a marvelous job of communicating an enormous depth of history and culture that the story is set in. Inside of “Dune” there is an entire universe, one that is truly alien. During the first fifty of so pages, this feeling of strangeness is all but overwhelming. I don't think I understood even half of what is spoken or referenced during the first hour of reading. The beginning is where Herbert truly sets himself apart from amateur writers, though. After the first hour I began to understand, through induction, cultural osmosis, and cleverly placed contextual hints more and more of the worlds and words of “Dune”. Eventually I became so acclimated to the world that it ceased to seem peculiar. It was a fascinating experience.
All of this wordsmith showmanship probably makes “Dune” sound pretentious and high minded; to a certain extent it is. In the grand tradition of soft science fiction it works in gigantic amounts of details and philosophic musings about culture, ecology, religion, and politics. At the same time, however, “Dune” incorporates many classic tropes of the genre: blood feuds, emotionless assassins, psychics, genetically manipulated super-beings, seers, a cult who trains its members in Sherlock Holmes style skills of observance, etc. For all its philosophical pondering and subtle cultural criticisms, “Dune” is still a fun and engaging story.
The only substantial weakness I could find dwells in Herbert's writing style. Mainly, he uses ellipses excessively (to the tune of several per page). If each of these pauses are “sounded out” in the reader's head, the occasionally awkward dialog becomes stilted and unbelievable. It didn't take me long to start ignoring the ellipses; I recommend other readers do the same.
I don't know what I expected out of “Dune” but those expectations were certainly met. I recommend this story to all fans of the science fiction and fantasy genres. It really is a classic and a grand achievement of imagination. Herbert gambled on a unique literary approach and won... and crafted a fine story to boot. If that was not enough, “Dune” also has four appendices. 10/10
Where an
Eidolon, named night, on a black throne reigns upright.