Postby ich1990 » Sun Jul 26, 2009 2:03 pm
“Exploring Romans” by John Phillips
Phillips must have been a pastor before he was an exegete. I started this book expecting it to provide a thorough, analytical analyses of the book of Romans. Instead, it essentially gave me a collection of sermons on the letter of Romans disguised as a commentary. Personally, I was looking for something a bit drier, but it wasn't unpleasant.
Like most sermons, the primary goal of this volume was to make the Bible seem interesting, hip, and relevant to the modern reader. As a result, Phillips frequently resorted to analogies, loosely related stories, outright speculations, and at least one non-sequitur. Sometimes this helped to make Romans seem more vivid. Other times, it drove his commentary completely off track and onto his personal soapboxes (evolution, capital punishment, Just War Theory, etc.).
The asides were usually tolerable, however, because Phillips generally provided useful comments along the way. For instance, he went out of his way to unite the entire Bible with the book of Romans. Paul frequently quotes portions of the Old Testament to show that Christianity is not a new religion but perfected Judaism. Phillips followed closely in Paul's footsteps, not only explaining Paul's selection of verses, but also adding his own correlating verses. Additionally, Phillips spends a great deal of time situating the letter to the Romans among Paul's other missionary journeys and letters. Both of these emphases went a long way towards painting the “bigger picture” of what Romans is all about.
It is a solid volume, if not spectacular or faultless. If the potential reader comes from a conservative or Evangelical theological persuasion, then “Exploring Romans” will well serve them as a readable, introductory commentary on Paul's great letter. 7/10
“Some Fruits of Solitude” by William Penn
Two decades of reading has well cemented a fact in my mind; when it comes to searching for wisdom or thought provocation, a reader can rarely do better then study the writings of old dead people. Therefore, when I discovered a complete set of “The Harvard Classics” --a full twenty-three thousand pages of old dead people's writings-- hiding in a corner of my grandparents' basement, it was like stumbling across a stasis chamber holding King Solomon. Despite having half a hundred books already on my list to read (this summer), I couldn't help but take home the first volume in the series and find out what the founder of Pennsylvania had learned during his time of isolation.
The setup of “Some Fruits...” is quite similar to that of Proverbs. It contains about 850 single sentence aphorisms that are arranged according to theme. Many of these statements are quite striking and have a ring of truth to them: “And he that is taught to live upon a little, owes more to his Father's Wisdom, than he that has a great deal left him, does to his Father's Care.”
Penn also has a curmudgeon's sense of humor: “'T is a Happiness to be delivered from a Curious Mind, as well as from a Dainty Palate.”
All told, however, many of these profound statements have little usefulness outside of the proverbial cocktail party; even when the one-liners are practical, they usually overlap with Proverbs. “Some Fruits of Solitude” is entertaining to read, has plenty of quotable quotes, contains loads of random capitalization, but, unfortunately, doesn't go much beyond that. 8/10
Where an
Eidolon, named night, on a black throne reigns upright.