These titles are NOT what we consider to be anti-Christian. The purpose of this list is to keep the peace, not tell you which shows you should or shouldn't watch. These titles were selected because they have caused trouble in the past or are extremely likely to given the content.
The staff has decided it would be extremely beneficial for us to post which titles we'd prefer not be discussed. These titles are either highly controversial, extremely inappropriate, or both. We have noticed all discussions in the past on these titles has only erupted into tension, rude posts, etc., for the sake of keeping the peace, these are the titles we ask you discuss privately amongst yourselves via PM or off-site...
Hats wrote:"Frodo! Cast off your [s]sins[/s] into the fire!"
FllMtl Novelist (post: 1589907) wrote:Well, if you want to get technical about it...
FMA hasn't (since I joined) caused trouble. It's neither highly controversial nor extremely inappropriate.
And honestly, if we banned/frowned on discussion of any/every anime that wasn't explicitly religious and/or Christian, there really wouldn't be much left to talk about, and not much point to the site.
[SIZE="1"]Also, I'm sorry, but science is bad? Are you serious? xD]
Crossfire (post: 1589904) wrote:
Edit'd to better reflect my response.
FllMtl Novelist (post: 1589907) wrote:Well, if you want to get technical about it...
FMA hasn't (since I joined) caused trouble. It's neither highly controversial nor extremely inappropriate.
And honestly, if we banned/frowned on discussion of any/every anime that wasn't explicitly religious and/or Christian, there really wouldn't be much left to talk about, and not much point to the site.
[SIZE="1"]Also, I'm sorry, but science is bad? Are you serious? xD]
goldenspines (post: 1589961) wrote:Ah, so you didn't see beyond the first episode? It's a common response for the first two episodes to create a more extreme response from viewers.
Ed does indeed say he gave up on religion and claims alchemists are the "closest thing there is to god."
But skip a few episodes ahead and Ed and his brother Al learn a painful lesson through a series of events and the SAME character, Ed, who was so cocky only episodes previously says the following:
"I know we're not gods. We're humans. WE'RE ONLY HUMAN! Who can't even do anything to save one innocent little girl... so what good are we then?"
Note: I am quoting the remake of the anime Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. But the quote appears in the first anime (though worded slightly differently) as well as the manga.
It's as they say, you can't fully judge a book by its cover. In the same way, you often can't always judge an anime by it's first episode. (see: Fate/Zero)
Imperial (post: 1589897) wrote:As its all about Hieratic's And Athiests and is anti-religion as Edward Elric said he "gave up"/ quit beliving in god in the first season and the seires is all chimera-tecnologie and science and most of the alchemists there are athiests
goldenspines (post: 1589961) wrote:Ah, so you didn't see beyond the first episode? It's a common response for the first two episodes to create a more extreme response from viewers.
Ed does indeed say he gave up on religion and claims alchemists are the "closest thing there is to god."
(see: Fate/Zero)
Hats wrote:"Frodo! Cast off your [s]sins[/s] into the fire!"
Xeno (post: 1590036) wrote:Uhhh, how is a voice actor's faith in any way indicative of the religious content (or lack thereof) of an anime or anything else?
Additional note: Vic is an English VA, meaning he was not the voice actor selected by the original production company of the anime to voice that character. Further proving his faith means nothing in relation to the religious content of FMA.
Xeno wrote:Uhhh, how is a voice actor's faith in any way indicative of the religious content (or lack thereof) of an anime or anything else?
Return to Anime and Anime Reviews
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 272 guests