CAA: Christian Anime Alliance

I think the best are from:

• Gypsy (although I disagree with her review of Project A-ko. I give it an 8 myself.
• Mangafanatic
• CDLViking
• Rev. Doc
• That Dude
• shoorajin
• true_noir_chloe
• Ashley
• myself (okay, cheap plug!)

I dunno, this can lead to more favoritism...

Yeah, no offence Rocklobster but this isn`t a great idea for a thread.

I appreciate that you find our reviews helpful, but it should be remembered that it isn't a competition. We're simply trying to do our part to serve the community.

Yeah, no offence Rocklobster but this isn`t a great idea for a thread.

now be nice he is only trying to have fun ^_^ anyways they are all good

I chose this thread because I wanted to know who serves as the best model for newbies who want to try their hand at this review thing.

AnimeJump does. ANIMEJUMP!

Also, Zac Bertschy is pretty good, despite my extreme distaste for the man's attitude and inability to conduct himself in a civil manner.

So, no, I'm not voting for any CAA filks. Sorry. ; )

Honestly I agree with the other CAAers with this. This is not a good thread to start, where it seems to flame/ show favoritism to certain people. Honestly, this :

true_noir_chloe (too bad he/she is banned )

Was rather tacky and rude to the people you personally didn't like.

This is a thing that involves a person's personal opinion and not necessarily needs to be shared with everyone on CAA.

-Kami

Or Maybe he really is upset that he/she left.

Well if that WAS the case then maybe he should have said it in a nicer way.

Or maybe it was tacky and rude. =(

-Kami

Just so we can dispense with the he/she, true_noir_chloe is a woman.

As to reviewers, I've never really read the reviews here. My tendency is to just get personal recommendations from people I know.

I'd like to request that all mention of banned members and the curcuimstances surrounding those members exit from the CAA scene die down. We're just giving a thread about people who we believe contribute a lot to CAA through the detail of their reviews.

sorry I brought up such a touchy topic, Osaka. Never mind that comment.

rocklobster wrote:sorry I brought up such a touchy topic, Osaka. Never mind that comment.

It's okay. I've gone ahead and snipped the little phrase that was causing trouble.