Postby ich1990 » Fri May 16, 2008 7:44 am
Just finished "The Ball and the Cross" by G.K. Chesterton.
On a whole, I liked it much more than "The Man Who Was Thursday". While it was not quite as uproariously funny, it was much more lucid.
Basically, the story examines the definition of insanity within religious context. The story follows two characters, one a passionate Atheist and one a passionate Catholic, who come into conflict with each other. These two immediately find that their views are incompatible, so they decide to fight a duel to the death. However, whenever they try to kill each other, they are stopped by one circumstance or another. Along the way, the book comes to question, "who is really mad?". Is it the two duelists who are driven to kill because of their beliefs, or is it the relativistic world which doesn't have anything worth fighting for? This book is not really about Atheist versus Catholic, but about Conviction versus Apathy.
One thing that became apparent to me upon reading this book, is that: If Shakespeare is the Prince of Paradox, then G.K. Chesterton is the King. Over and over paradox after paradox are piled upon each other. If taken at face value, these paradoxes seem to make little sense, but, upon further inspection, each and every one of them holds a little gem of truth. These paradoxes add much depth to the book, and will leave you much to think about well after you put down the book.
If there is one thing to complain about in this book, it is the lack of stability. The book changes from sword fighting, to a horse race, to theological musings, to airships (yes like in Final Fantasy), and back to swordfighting with startling rapidity. It seems as if G.K.C. sat around and came up with a nice pile of paradoxes and witty sayings, then came up with a story that worked as many of these one-liners in as possible. The result is a haphazard, yet thoroughly entertaining and witty book that takes time to examine deep theological issues. If you are looking for an action/adventure book, you may want to look elsewere, but if you are looking for an entertaining and easy to read philosophical book with plenty of action, then this is it. Rating 10/10
Where an
Eidolon, named night, on a black throne reigns upright.